The Four Horsemen of Divorce: How to Prevent Relationship Collapse

• Dr. Brian Clemmons, Ph.D. LMHC, LPC

---

Introduction: The Predictors of Divorce and What You Can Do

Did you know that researchers can predict divorce with startling accuracy? It turns out, how couples communicate during arguments is a major clue. Dr. John Gottman, a renowned researcher from the University of Washington, spent years observing couples. He identified specific destructive communication patterns that often signal the end of a relationship. By understanding these patterns, couples can learn to change their behavior and build stronger bonds.

The John Gottman Research: Identifying Relationship Disasters

Gottman's team watched couples interact in apartment settings. They closely analyzed the communication styles of both happy and unhappy couples. This research allowed them to distinguish between relationship "masters" and "disasters." The "disasters" often used specific phrases and actions that led to separation. Gottman's findings provide a roadmap for understanding what breaks relationships.

Understanding the "Four Horsemen"

These destructive patterns are famously known as "The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse." They represent four types of communication that can spell doom for a marriage. Recognizing these "horsemen" is the first step toward preventing them. Learning their signs and, more importantly, how to counter them, can save your relationship.

Horseman 1: Criticism - The Character Attack

What Criticism Is and How It Manifests

Criticism isn't just complaining about a specific action. It's an attack on your partner's character. Think "you always" or "you never" statements. For example, saying "You always leave your socks on the floor" is criticism. It implies a flaw in your partner's very being, not just a single instance of forgetfulness. This kind of attack makes people feel blamed and misunderstood.

The Solution: Shifting to Gentle Complaint

The antidote to criticism is a gentle complaint. Instead of attacking character, focus on the specific issue. Frame it without blame. For instance, try saying, "I feel overwhelmed by the laundry when the floor is messy. Could you help me tidy up?" This approach expresses your needs without attacking your partner. It opens the door for cooperation rather than defensiveness.

Horseman 2: Defensiveness - The Innocent Victim Stance

The Nature of Defensiveness in Conflict

Defensiveness is a natural response when we feel attacked. It's like putting up a shield. When your partner criticizes you, you might feel unfairly accused. You might then try to prove your innocence or shift blame. This often comes out as making excuses or playing the victim. Unfortunately, defensiveness prevents any real problem-solving from happening.

The Solution: Owning Your Part

The solution to defensiveness is to take responsibility. Even if you feel only 1% responsible, owning your part can de-escalate conflict. Acknowledge your contribution to the issue. Instead of saying, "It's not my fault!" try to see the other person's perspective. Owning your actions, however small, shows you're willing to work together. It builds trust and understanding.

Horseman 3: Stonewalling - The Withdrawal of Connection

Understanding Stonewalling and Its Causes

Stonewalling is when someone emotionally withdraws during a disagreement. They shut down and become unresponsive. This often happens when a person feels overwhelmed or "flooded." They might feel like nothing they say will make a difference. Gottman's research found that men are more prone to stonewalling. This happens when they feel flooded by emotion and enter fight-or-flight mode.

The Solution: Self-Soothing and Down-Regulation of emotions

The key to overcoming stonewalling is self-soothing. Learn to calm yourself down when emotions run high. If you feel overwhelmed, take a break from the conversation. Step away to regulate your emotions before re-engaging. This allows you to return to the discussion with a clearer head. It prevents the conversation from shutting down completely.

Horseman 4: Contempt - The Superiority Complex

The Manifestations of Contempt

Contempt is perhaps the most destructive horseman. It's when you communicate with an attitude of superiority. This can include sarcasm, mockery, or eye-rolling. Think of patronizing tones or making fun of your partner. These actions communicate disdain. They signal that you see your partner as beneath you. Contempt erodes respect and intimacy in the relationship.

The Solution: Cultivating Appreciation and Pride

The best way to combat contempt is to build a culture of appreciation. Regularly focus on your partner's positive qualities. Express gratitude and pride in them. Consciously shift your thoughts from negative judgments to positive affirmations. Build your partner up instead of tearing them down. This practice fosters a more loving and respectful connection.

Conclusion: Building a Healthier Relationship

Recap of the Four Horsemen and Their Solutions

We've explored the Four Horsemen: Criticism, Defensiveness, Stonewalling, and Contempt. Each represents a damaging communication style that can lead to divorce. Remember, criticism attacks character, defensiveness deflects blame, stonewalling withdraws, and contempt shows disdain. The solutions involve shifting to gentle complaints, owning your part, self-soothing, and fostering appreciation.

The Path to Lasting Relationships

Building a healthy, lasting relationship takes conscious effort. By understanding and actively working against these Four Horsemen, you can strengthen your connection. Make these strategies a regular part of your communication. You can create a more supportive and loving partnership. Your relationship's future depends on the communication habits you build today.

• Dr. Brian Clemmons, Ph.D. LMHC, LPC